42nd Street Pizza

647 W 42nd St, New York, NY 10036 Order now
Hero image

Our reviews

Reviews from Grubhub

42nd Street Pizza Reviews on Grubhub

Brian

3 reviews
Super nice. Restaurant called as soon as delivery was en route to let me know. Delivery guy was great AND they threw in some freebies with a nice note!

David

Top Reviewer
Ive had a lot of disappointing pizza here. This was awesome. And huge. Very friendly delivery guy. Food was hot and delicious. Highly recommend!

Joe

Top Reviewer
Just moved into the building next door - we were hoping this place would be good! It was good.

Barry

Top Reviewer
Pizzas really tasty, order from here! Try the lasagna one

Carlos

2 reviews
I love their breakfast. I order it everytime.

Reviews from Seamless.com

42nd Street Pizza Reviews on Seamless

laura

1 review
I will start off by saying that I am a pizza girl. I like pizza. It's good. So, you can imagine how excited I was when I moved to New York City last year. PIZZA. EVERYDAY. FOR ALL OF THE DAYS. I tried it on the street. I tried it at so many corner stores I can't even remember. And then... I tried 42nd Street Pizza. And theeeeennn, I swore off any other pizza ever invented. Only this place for the rest of my life please do not show me any other pizza nor take me to Italy for pizza it will not work I refuse I have found my happy place none of your jabbing will ever convince me otherwise no matter where I am in this god-forsaken pizza loving world because it will not work ever. EVER. This place has the nicest staff, best sandwiches, and did I mention the pizza? Do yourself a favor: Go there and change your life forever.

Lila

1 review
Virginia Ham triple Decker Deluxe was more of tomato and lettuce than ham. If you order, be sure to have cheese, mine did not. Should have more meat I know my salad had more meat. Chef's salad with olive oil and Balsamic vinegar dressing was good, but make sure dressing in on side, can be too much for some people. Otherwise, when I ordered, I made sure there was enough time to deliver promptly and it arrived 10 mins early. Two thumbs up on that. The price was right on the salad, but a little too high for the sandwhich and fries. Oh yes, fries were perfect and my meal arrived hot. I was satisfied compared to other places that I have ordered from. Good Job 42nd Street Restaurant and Pizza.

Mike

Top Reviewer
I order from these guys all the time. Though I am fond of their pizza, their breakfast selection is even better--their French Toast is the best in Hell's Kitchen. Delivery time is generally as advertised, and the food is always well packaged to avoid spills. I reserve five star reviews for those establishments which *consistently* provide excellent service. Most restaurants disappoint me from time to time, but 42nd Street Restaurant and Pizza is always a safe bet.

Chen

Top Reviewer
We ordered a large pizza with sausage and jalapenos. The delivery was prompt and the pizza was nice and hot. All in all, it was a pretty solid thin crust pizza. This pizza has great reheat-ability, taste and texture largely preserved after a night in the fridge and a nuking in the microwave. My only concern is that the jalapenos were a bit too weak.

Lenard

1 review
5 ***** cha, Cha, cha !!! I know Pizza! From $$$ pizza that has the sweet yet tangy sauce to the Stellar Za of 42nd Streets Finest. A crust that doesn't make my Pants Fall Down. 42nd st Pizza Stands Up Consistently with a Supercalafragalistic Pizza everytime. Quality Za, All The Time... Thank You for Keeping my Pants On! Epicureans Delight -

About us

Dessert, Diner, Dinner, Greek, Hamburgers, Pasta, Pizza, Salads, Seafood
Today
Delivery: 11:00 AM - 8:00 PM
Takeout: 10:00 AM - 9:00 PM